Battlefield homeowners comparing Malarkey Legacy and GAF Timberline AS II are looking at two premium impact-resistant shingle choices. Malarkey Legacy uses NEX rubberized asphalt and includes Scotchgard Protector algae protection. GAF Timberline AS II uses SBS-modified asphalt and is built around Class 4 impact resistance. Both can be strong choices after hail damage, but they come from different roofing systems.
Quick answer:
Malarkey Legacy and GAF Timberline AS II are both strong impact-resistant options. Legacy may appeal to homeowners wanting NEX rubberized asphalt and Scotchgard algae protection, while AS II may appeal to homeowners wanting GAF SBS-modified asphalt and system familiarity.
Local help
Why homeowners call Storm Damage Repair Contractors
Storm Damage Repair Contractors helps homeowners in Battlefield, Missouri understand roofing, gutter, storm damage, and exterior water concerns in plain language before approving work.
- Clear inspection and estimate help
- Practical repair, replacement, or monitoring options
- Local service help in Battlefield, Missouri
Why Compare Legacy And AS II
Both products are often considered when homeowners want a stronger roof after hail damage. They compete in the impact-resistant architectural shingle category.
Legacy Strengths
Legacy offers NEX rubberized asphalt, Class 4 impact resistance, Scotchgard Protector algae protection, and Malarkey's sustainability story.
Need storm damage help?
Get help with your roof, gutters, or storm damage
Whether the issue is a leak, aging shingles, hail damage, wind damage, or exterior water concerns, Storm Damage Repair Contractors can help review the issue and explain the next step.
AS II Strengths
GAF Timberline AS II uses SBS-modified asphalt and is positioned as a Class 4 impact-resistant Timberline option.
Storm Damage Still Happens
Both products can still be damaged by severe hail, wind, or debris. Class 4 impact resistance is not a guarantee against all damage.
System And Warranty Differences
The decision should include starter shingles, ridge caps, underlayment, ventilation, leak barrier, contractor qualifications, and warranty terms.
Best Choice For Battlefield Homes
Legacy may be best for homeowners who like Malarkey's premium feature set. AS II may be best for homeowners who want to stay within the GAF roofing system.
Frequently Asked Questions
Are both Class 4 shingles?
Both are commonly promoted as Class 4 impact-resistant options, but current documents should be verified.
Which has better algae protection?
Legacy Scotchgard includes Scotchgard Protector; GAF has separate algae protection options depending on product.
Can either roof still leak after hail?
Yes, if storm damage affects shingles, flashing, vents, or roof accessories.
Should I compare roof systems?
Yes. The full system matters as much as the shingle brand.
Storm Damage Repair Contractors
Schedule A Battlefield Malarkey Roof Inspection
If your Battlefield home has Malarkey shingles or you are comparing storm-damage replacement options, a professional inspection can help you understand repair, replacement, and documentation options.
Request Help Today